Insurance Companies

To better assist you, the following carriers have 24-hour direct claim reporting services available. Prior to calling, please have your policy number and claim details available for the claims adjuster. The insurance carrier will forward a copy of your claim report to our office.

Please remember to call The Mitchell Agency within 24 hours of any Claims reported directly to the Insurance Companies to ensure all information is received correctly. Call us at 973-383-5800.

If your company is NOT listed below, click here so you can fill-out a Mitchell claims reporting form.

If you would like to speak with a member of our staff for any reason, please do not hesitate to call them or to contact our main office.

Partners Listing and Claims Info:

Aetna
Aetna

860-273-0123 • www.aetna.com
Amerihealth
Amerihealth
732-726-6700 • www.amerihealth.com
ARI Insurance
ARI Insurance Company
800-820-4506 • www.ari-ins.com
Blue Cross Blue Shield
BlueCross Blue Sheild
800-355-BLUE (2583) • www.horizon-bcbsnj.com
Cumberland Insurance
Cumberland Mutual Insurance Company
800-232-6992 • www.cumberlandgroup.com
Encompass Insurance
Encompass Insurance Company
800-588-7400 • www.encompassinsurance.com
Foremost Insurance
Foremost Insurance Company

800-532-4221 • www.foremost.com
Franklin Mutual Insurance Company
FMI / Franklin Mutual Insurance Company
973-948-3120 • www.fmiweb.com
Oxford Health Plan
Oxford Insurance
800-444-6222 • www.oxhp.com

Pallisades Insurance
Palisades Insurance Company

877-725-6423 • www.palisades.com

Peerless Insurance
Peerless Insurance Company

800-542-5385 • www.peerless-ins.com
Pay your Peerless Bill online click here

Penn Millers Insurance
Penn Millers Insurance Company

800-233-8347 • www.pennmillers.com

Preferred Mutual Insurance
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

800-333-7642 • www.pminsco.com
Progressive Insurance
Progressive Insurance Company

800-PROGRESSIVE • www.progressive.com
Selective Insurance
Selective Insurance Company

866-455-9969 • www.selective.com
The Hartford Insurance Comany
The Hartford Insurance Company

860-547-5000 • www.thehartford.com

Travels insurance
Travelers Insurance
(800)-252-4633 (800.CLAIM33) • www.travelers.com

Zurich insurance of North America
Zurich North America Insurance Company

800-382-2150 • www.zurichna.com