The Mitchell Insurance Agency has been a family owned and operated business in NJ for over 45 years. We provide insurance for your business and personal needs. We pride ourselves on providing excellent service to our clients. The Mitchell Agency represents over 15 insurance companies to service your insurance needs. We offer insurance in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and New York.

At the Mitchell Insurance Agency, we believe the best source for your insurance is an independent agent. We will provide someone with the integrity and professionalism who takes the time to learn about your specific needs and create the best possible insurance program and price that will be valuable to you.

The Mitchell Agency is proud to announce it has received the "Best Insurance Agency of the Year" of Sussex County award for the third year in a row from the NJ Herald. This award is voted on by the local clients and readers of the paper. Thank you to all that voted.

More About Us:

  • National Association of Professional Insurance Agents® (PIA) Member
    Commercial Insurance Services is proud to be a PIA ® insurance agency. This affiliation allows our staff to be aligned with independent Professional Insurance Agents in all 50 states, Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia. PIA members are local Main Street Agents who serve their communities throughout America.

Mitchell Insurance is proud to announce that they have been chosen to Selective’s 2008 President’s Club for the agency’s high standards in customer satisfaction, customer retention, sales and profitability. The President’s Club recognizes a select group of insurance agencies throughout the country for their achievements and outstanding performance.

News

The Mitchell Agency is proud to announce it has received the "Best Insurance Agency of the Year" of Sussex County award for the third year in a row from the NJ Herald. This award is voted on by the local clients and readers of the paper. Thank you to all who voted.